Motiva vs. Mentor Implants
Motiva vs. Mentor Implants: Lets Compare
When it comes to breast augmentation, selecting the right implant brand is a key part of the journey. Two of the most trusted and talked-about options on the market today are Motiva and Mentor. While both offer excellent outcomes, each brand has unique features, materials, shapes, and technologies designed to suit different goals and body types.
This guide will help you understand the differences between Motiva and Mentor implants so you can make a more informed decision in consultation with our surgeons. From implant materials (saline vs silicone) and profile options to long-term safety data, warranties, and how long implants typically last we’ve covered the most important aspects to consider.
You'll also find tips on how to plan your breast augmentation journey, including how to choose the right size, prepare for surgery, and what to expect in terms of results and longevity.
Brand Background & Manufacturer
Mentor is a long-established leader in breast implants, part of Johnson & Johnson/J&J MedTech, with over 5 million implants used globally and a rich history dating back to the 1980s Learn More.
Motiva is made by Establishment Labs, manufactured in Costa Rica. It’s newer but rapidly innovating with next generation implants Learn More.
Implant Types & Gel Consistency
Mentor
Offers a wide variety:
Silicone cohesive gel: MemoryGel, MemoryGel Xtra, MemoryShape and MemoryGel BOOST for different levels of fullness and projection Centre for Surgery.
Saline option, though less commonly used .
Shell textures: smooth or textured (SIL-TEX) Berks Plastic Surgery.
Motiva
Silicone-only lineup, featuring:
Round implants (ProgressiveGel PLUS).
Ergonomix: designed to mimic natural tissue movement (round when lying down, teardrop when upright).
Anatomical TrueFixation: offers a teardrop shape with enhanced positioning stability drzykov.com.
Shell features: ultra‑smooth surface (SmoothSilk), BluSeal barrier layer to prevent gel bleed, and Q Inside micro-transponder for implant tracking People.com.
Look, Feel & Movement
Mentor’s cohesive gel provides a fairly natural feel with reliable shape retention; texture options help anchor anatomical implants cosmeditour.com.
Motiva Ergonomix aims for ultra-natural motion: softer gel allowing shape adaptation with body position, often feels more lifelike MYA Cosmetic Surgery.
Safety & Potential Risks
Mentor holds FDA approvals, offers standard warranties, and reports low rates of issues such as anaplastic large cell lymphoma (BIA‑ALCL) jnjmedtech.com. Cohesive gel reduces risks of leakage over time mentordirect.com.au.
Motiva emphasises enhanced safety with dual-barrier shells and reduced capsular contracture risk (reported <0.6% at 4 years) Daniel Brown MD. The Q Inside chip aids in long-term tracking
Range of Sizes & Profiles
Mentor covers a broad spectrum: from teardrop anatomical shapes to high-profile round options, with multiple cohesive levels and smooth/textured shells Dr Michael Kernohan.
Motiva centers around versatility using its Ergonomix model to offer a hybrid profile that suits many preferences; size range spans mini (105 cc) to extra‑large (up to 1050 cc) Centre for Surgery.
Warranty & Support
Mentor provides established warranty programs and clear replacement policies for ruptures or capsular contracture .
Motiva includes robust coverage with tracking tech for identification and strong safety backing in its warranty epsteinplasticsurgery.com.
Real-World Insight
According to many plastic surgeons, Mentor is trusted for consistency and its long-standing reputation, while Motiva is praised for its innovation and implants that “move like natural tissue” Daniel Brown MD.
Users on forums like RealSelf share:
“Motiva are not softer or more natural feeling than Mentor they feel the same… Mentor is a better company, with a longer track record… implants last longer…” People.com
But celebrity endorsements underscore Motiva’s soft, natural feel like Meghan Trainor, who chose Motiva SmoothSilk Ergonomix for her augmentation in early 2025, calling them “cutie booties” and noting their natural feel with <1% complication risk Dr John Burns.
Choosing Between Them
Final Thoughts
Choose Mentor if you value a proven track record, warranty clarity, and a wide selection.
Choose Motiva if you seek cutting-edge design, movement that mimics natural tissue, and tech-enhanced safety.
Ultimately, your plastic surgeon’s assessment based on your anatomy, lifestyle, and goals should guide the final choice. They’ll help align implant style, shape, and size with your expectations and physiology.